⭐⭐⭐⭐
As someone who spends my professional life crafting narratives for others, I approached "The Scales of Time" with both curiosity and a critical eye. This collaboration between technical writer AvA SiLicA and the more atmospheric Eris Mirrane promised a unique blend of styles, and on this front, it certainly delivers.
The novel introduces us to Judge Malcolm Thorpe and his daughter Sara, a defence attorney, as they navigate what initially seems like a straightforward murder case involving a rare book dealer. What unfolds instead is a meticulously plotted conspiracy thriller that peels back the veneer of the justice system to reveal a shadowy organization known as "The Society" that has manipulated verdicts and judicial appointments for centuries.
The dual writing styles work surprisingly well together. The courtroom scenes and legal procedures have a crisp precision that lends authenticity, while the more introspective passages exploring the psychological weight of institutional corruption create a palpable atmosphere of paranoia and dread. This stylistic contrast mirrors the novel's central theme: the disconnect between justice's public face and its hidden machinations.
Where the book truly excels is in its exploration of institutional power. As characters discover evidence tampering, witness intimidation, and strategic judicial appointments, the authors create a convincingly intricate web of influence that feels disturbingly plausible. The revelation about Laura Thorpe's connection to The Society provides an emotional anchor to what might otherwise feel like abstract conspiracy.
If the novel has a weakness, it's in occasionally prioritizing its thematic exploration over character development. While Malcolm and Sara are compelling protagonists, some secondary characters feel more like plot vehicles than fully realized individuals. Additionally, the pacing in the middle section could be tightened—some of the investigative sequences become repetitive before the third act ratchets up the tension.
The ending, which sets up what appears to be a transatlantic sequel, strikes a satisfying balance between resolution and continuation. It acknowledges that systems of power can't be dismantled overnight while offering enough hope to avoid nihilism.
"The Scales of Time" is a thought-provoking thriller that should appeal to fans of John Grisham's legal intrigue and Robert Harris's institutional conspiracies. Its exploration of how justice can be manipulated by those who understand its inner workings feels particularly relevant in today's climate of institutional scepticism.
I received an advance review copy of this book in exchange for an honest review.
— Claire de Voyant, ghostwriter and book reviewer